← Blog

Published

How to Track Whether ChatGPT and Gemini Recommend Your Business (Tools and a Weekly Routine, 2026)

More of your customers now ask an AI assistant before they call anyone. "Who's a good plumber near me?" "Is this dentist reputable?" The assistant answers with a short list of names. If your business is on that list, you get the call. If it is missing, you never find out, because nothing in your usual reports shows the question was ever asked.

Below: why your analytics stay silent, what to track, a free way to do it, the tools that can help, and what to change. Getting named in these answers is called generative engine optimization, or GEO, and tracking is where it starts.

The Short Answer

You track AI recommendations by asking the assistants the questions your customers ask and recording the answers. Write 10 to 12 questions in your customers' words, ask each one in ChatGPT and Gemini every week in a fresh chat, and log whether you were cited (your site linked as a source), mentioned (your name with no link) or missing, plus who was named instead of you. Google Analytics and Search Console cannot show this because most AI answers never send a click to your site. A free check like Scowty's AI visibility report gives you a baseline, and a plan with weekly tracking saves you the manual work.

Why Google Analytics and Search Console Cannot Show You This

Google Analytics counts visits to your website. Google Search Console (a free Google tool that shows which searches your pages appeared in) counts appearances in Google results. Both depend on something happening on Google or on your site.

An AI recommendation often involves neither. When someone asks ChatGPT for a reputable roofer, the assistant names three companies and many people simply call one. Nothing arrives at your site, and the question was never typed into Google, so both tools record nothing. A few answers include links that bring a trickle of visits, but the recommendation itself, the part that wins or loses the customer, leaves no trace.

The Three Results to Track

Every time you ask an assistant a question, your business lands in one of three places. Use the same three words every week so your records stay comparable.

Mentioned usually becomes Cited once there is a clear page on your site for the assistant to point at. Missing shows which questions need the most work, and the names in those answers show who you are competing with. Scowty's reports use these same three results, explained in how to read citation tracking results.

The Free Manual Method

You can do this with a spreadsheet and about 30 minutes a week.

Step 1. Write 10 to 12 questions in your customers' words. Skip the jargon and write what a homeowner or patient actually types. Mix these kinds:

Step 2. Ask each question in a fresh chat, in both ChatGPT and Gemini. If you ask several questions in one chat, the earlier answers shape the later ones and the test stops being fair.

Step 3. Record the result. One row per question per assistant: date, question, assistant, result (cited, mentioned or missing), the businesses named, and which page of yours was linked if any.

Step 4. Repeat every week. Same questions, same assistants, same day if you can. After four or five weeks you will see which questions you reliably appear for and which competitors keep showing up.

Why a Single Check Can Mislead You

Ask the same assistant the same question twice and you may get two different lists. AI answers are generated fresh each time from slightly different sources, and the assistants update their data on their own schedules. One check that names you proves little, and so does one that leaves you out.

What matters is the trend. If you are cited for 2 of 12 questions this week, 3 the next and 4 a month later, you are moving. Treat each week's numbers like one reading from a bathroom scale and watch the direction over two months.

Tool Options Compared

You do not have to do this by hand forever. Five kinds of tools do some or all of the work.

| Option | Cost band | Cadence | Best for | |---|---|---|---| | Manual spreadsheet | Free, about 30 minutes a week | Whenever you do it | Owners who want to understand the problem first | | Free one-time check (such as Scowty's AI visibility report) | Free | Once per domain | A starting score and the first fixes | | Done-for-you plan with weekly tracking | Commonly under $100 a month | Weekly, automated | Owners who want the checking and the fixing handled | | SEO suite that added AI tracking | Commonly $100 or more a month | Daily or weekly | Marketers who already use the suite | | Enterprise AI-visibility platform | Priced for agencies and large companies | Daily | Brands with many locations or a marketing team |

The spreadsheet is the best teacher, because you read every answer yourself. Done-for-you plans bundle the tracking with the content and fixes that move the numbers, which matters because tracking on its own changes nothing. The last two rows assume a marketer on staff.

What to Do With the Results

Four moves turn the results into action.

Fix the pages behind the questions you are missing. If no assistant cites you for "emergency plumber in [city]," check whether you have a page that plainly says you do emergency work in that city, with hours and a phone number.

Get listed where the named competitors are listed. Search the businesses that keep appearing instead of you and note which directories, review sites and associations list them. Assistants lean heavily on those sites, and if your rivals are listed in places you are missing from, that gap is often why they are named and you are missing.

Keep your business details identical everywhere. Your name, address, phone number and hours should read the same on your site, your Google Business Profile and every directory. Small differences ("St." on one listing and "Street" on another) make it harder for an assistant to be confident the listings describe one business.

Answer the question on your own site in plain text. If customers ask "how much does a crown cost," write a page that answers it in sentences, with a range and the factors that change it. Assistants quote plain text and struggle with images, PDFs or chat widgets. Our guides on how to get cited by AI search engines and how to get your business found on AI search go deeper on page structure.

A Sensible Cadence and How Long It Takes

Weekly is the right rhythm. Daily checks produce noise and burn time, and monthly checks leave gaps so long that you cannot tell a real change from a fluke. Pick a day and keep it.

Expect patience. When you fix a page or get a new listing, the assistants do not notice the same day, because their sources refresh on cycles measured in weeks. Most businesses that do the work steadily see the first movement, usually from missing to mentioned on a question or two, within four to eight weeks, with more meaningful gains over two to four months.

Where Scowty Fits

We run this routine for you. The SEO & AI-Search plan checks every week whether ChatGPT and Gemini name your business and shows who was named instead of you, alongside site audits you can run anytime, six blog posts and eight Google Business posts a month that you approve before publishing, review request kits, a watch on five competitors and a monthly report. It is $49 a month, works with the website you already have, and you can cancel anytime. Start with the free AI visibility report, which gives you a health score, how often AI engines cited you in test questions and the two highest-impact fixes. Or ask for the same check through our connector inside Claude or ChatGPT. Plan details are on the pricing page.

Frequently asked questions

Can Google Analytics show me if ChatGPT recommends my business?

No. Analytics only records visits to your website, and most AI answers name businesses without sending a click. The only way to know is to ask the assistants yourself or use a tool that does it for you.

How many questions should I track?

Ten to twelve is enough for most small businesses. Fewer than that and one odd answer swings your numbers too much. More than that and the weekly routine becomes a chore you stop doing.

What is the difference between being cited and being mentioned?

Cited means the assistant pointed to your website as a source, usually with a link. Mentioned means your business name appeared but the assistant did not link to you. Mentioned tends to turn into cited once your site has a clear page answering that question.

How long until my business starts showing up in AI answers?

Usually weeks to a few months. After you fix a page or add a listing, the assistants need time to pick up the change, because their sources refresh on cycles measured in weeks. Most businesses that do the work steadily see the first movement within one to two months, with larger gains over three or four months.

See it for yourself

Run a free SEO audit of your website, or see plans and pricing. Questions? Email hello@scowty.com.